|
|
|
|
|
1
|
A bill to be entitled |
|
2
|
An act relating to medical malpractice insurance reform; |
|
3
|
creating a medical mutual insurance company; providing |
|
4
|
powers; providing purposes; providing for a board of |
|
5
|
directors; providing for membership; providing for |
|
6
|
appointment, qualifications, and terms of members; |
|
7
|
providing for the annual election of a chair; providing |
|
8
|
for compensation; providing for powers of the board; |
|
9
|
providing for the hiring of an administrator and for that |
|
10
|
administrator to act as the chief executive officer; |
|
11
|
providing duties of the administrator; requiring a bond; |
|
12
|
providing immunity from liability; providing for board |
|
13
|
determination of rates; providing for methodologies; |
|
14
|
specifying an investment policy; authorizing the board to |
|
15
|
determine such policy; authorizing the administrator to |
|
16
|
make investments; authorizing agents to sell certain |
|
17
|
policies; providing for commissions; requiring the |
|
18
|
administrator to develop a medical malpractice risk |
|
19
|
management program; providing for medical malpractice risk |
|
20
|
management plans; providing for premium effect of |
|
21
|
compliance with the program; prohibiting the company from |
|
22
|
receiving certain appropriations; providing an exception; |
|
23
|
authorizing the board to issue revenue bonds under certain |
|
24
|
circumstances; providing criteria, requirements, and |
|
25
|
procedures; limiting bonds sold to public entities; |
|
26
|
requiring audits; providing audit procedures; requiring |
|
27
|
audit reports to the Governor and Legislature; specifying |
|
28
|
report contents; requiring the administrator to formulate |
|
29
|
a budget; providing insurance carrier examination |
|
30
|
requirements for the Office of Insurance Regulation; |
|
31
|
requiring the office to set medical malpractice rates; |
|
32
|
providing requirements, responsibilities, and authority |
|
33
|
relating to rate filings; requiring medical malpractice |
|
34
|
insurers to file certain documents with the office; |
|
35
|
providing requirements; providing review authority of the |
|
36
|
office; authorizing the office to approve or disapprove |
|
37
|
rates; providing requirements and limitations; providing |
|
38
|
for setting new rates by the office; requiring notice; |
|
39
|
prohibiting the office from restricting certain insurer |
|
40
|
activities; providing construction relating to violations; |
|
41
|
providing for alternative compliance sufficiency; |
|
42
|
specifying initial rate submissions as inadequate or |
|
43
|
excessive under certain circumstances; amending s. |
|
44
|
627.062, F.S.; specifying nonapplication to professional |
|
45
|
medical malpractice insurance; creating s. 627.3518, F.S.; |
|
46
|
limiting rates for medical malpractice insurance; limiting |
|
47
|
rate increases to approvals by the Chief Financial |
|
48
|
Officer; creating s. 627.352, F.S.; prohibiting issuance |
|
49
|
of certain types of insurance policies without also |
|
50
|
issuing medical malpractice insurance policies; |
|
51
|
prohibiting denial of medical malpractice insurance to |
|
52
|
health care providers under certain circumstances; |
|
53
|
providing application; amending s. 627.357, F.S.; deleting |
|
54
|
a prohibition against forming a self-insurance fund; |
|
55
|
amending s. 766.314, F.S.; exempting certain persons from |
|
56
|
certain annual assessment payments; providing application; |
|
57
|
providing an effective date. |
|
58
|
|
|
59
|
Be It Enacted by the Legislature of the State of Florida: |
|
60
|
|
|
61
|
Section 1. Medical mutual insurance company created; |
|
62
|
powers; purpose.--The Medical Mutual Insurance Company is |
|
63
|
created as an independent public corporation for the purpose of |
|
64
|
insuring health care providers in this state against liability |
|
65
|
for loss, damage, or expense arising out of the death or injury |
|
66
|
of any person as a result of the negligence or malpractice of |
|
67
|
any health care provider. The company shall be organized and |
|
68
|
operated as a domestic mutual insurance company and shall not be |
|
69
|
a state agency. The company shall have the powers granted a |
|
70
|
general not-for-profit corporation. The company shall be a |
|
71
|
member of the state property and casualty guaranty association, |
|
72
|
and as such will be subject to assessments of the association, |
|
73
|
and the members of such association shall bear responsibility in |
|
74
|
the event of the insolvency of the company. The company shall |
|
75
|
use flexibility and experimentation in the development of types |
|
76
|
of policies and coverages offered to health care providers, |
|
77
|
subject to the approval of the director of the Office of |
|
78
|
Insurance Regulation. |
|
79
|
Section 2. Board created; members; appointment; |
|
80
|
qualifications; terms; chair.--
|
|
81
|
(1) A board of directors is established for the company. |
|
82
|
The board shall be appointed by July 1, 2003, and shall consist |
|
83
|
of five members appointed or selected as provided in this |
|
84
|
section. The Governor shall appoint the initial five members of |
|
85
|
the board with the advice and consent of the Senate. Each |
|
86
|
director shall serve a 5-year term. Terms shall be staggered so |
|
87
|
that no more than one director’s term expires each year on July |
|
88
|
1. The five directors initially appointed by the Governor shall |
|
89
|
determine their initial terms by lot. At the expiration of the |
|
90
|
term of any member of the board, the company’s policyholders |
|
91
|
shall elect a new director in accordance with provisions |
|
92
|
determined by the board.
|
|
93
|
(2) Any person may be a director who:
|
|
94
|
(a) Does not have any interest as a stockholder, employee, |
|
95
|
attorney, agent, broker, or contractor of an insurance entity |
|
96
|
who writes medical malpractice insurance or whose affiliates |
|
97
|
write medical malpractice insurance.
|
|
98
|
(b) Is of good moral character and who has never pleaded |
|
99
|
guilty to, or been found guilty of, a felony.
|
|
100
|
(3) The board shall annually elect a chair and any other |
|
101
|
officers the board deems necessary for the performance of its |
|
102
|
duties. Board committees and subcommittees may also be formed.
|
|
103
|
Section 3. Hiring of administrator; qualifications; |
|
104
|
compensation; powers of board; generally.--
|
|
105
|
(1) By October 1, 2003, the board shall hire an |
|
106
|
administrator who shall serve at the pleasure of the board, and |
|
107
|
the company shall be fully prepared to be operational by January |
|
108
|
1, 2004, and assume its responsibilities pursuant to this |
|
109
|
section. The administrator shall receive compensation as |
|
110
|
established by the board and must have proven successful |
|
111
|
experience as an executive at the general management level in |
|
112
|
the insurance business.
|
|
113
|
(2) The board is vested with full power, authority, and |
|
114
|
jurisdiction over the company. The board may perform all acts |
|
115
|
necessary or convenient in the administration of the company or |
|
116
|
in connection with the insurance business to be carried on by |
|
117
|
the company. In this regard, the board is empowered to function |
|
118
|
in all aspects as a governing body of a private insurance |
|
119
|
carrier.
|
|
120
|
Section 4. Administrator; duties; bond required; immunity |
|
121
|
from liability; board and employees.--
|
|
122
|
(1) The administrator of the company shall act as the |
|
123
|
company’s chief executive officer. The administrator shall be in |
|
124
|
charge of the day-to-day operations and management of the |
|
125
|
company.
|
|
126
|
(2) Before entering the duties of office, the |
|
127
|
administrator shall give an official bond in an amount and with |
|
128
|
sureties approved by the board. The premium for the bond shall |
|
129
|
be paid by the company.
|
|
130
|
(3) The administrator or his or her designee shall be the |
|
131
|
custodian of the moneys of the company, and all premiums, |
|
132
|
deposits, or other moneys paid to the company shall be deposited |
|
133
|
with a financial institution as designated by the administrator.
|
|
134
|
(4) No board member, officer, or employee of the company |
|
135
|
is liable in a private capacity for any act performed or |
|
136
|
obligation entered into when done in good faith, without intent |
|
137
|
to defraud, and in an official capacity in connection with the |
|
138
|
administration, management, or conduct of the company or affairs |
|
139
|
relating to it.
|
|
140
|
Section 5. Board to determine rates; methodology.--The |
|
141
|
board shall have full power and authority to establish rates to |
|
142
|
be charged by the company for insurance. The board shall |
|
143
|
contract for the services of or hire an independent actuary who |
|
144
|
is a member in good standing with the American Academy of |
|
145
|
Actuaries to develop and recommend actuarially sound rates. |
|
146
|
Rates shall be set at amounts sufficient, when invested, to |
|
147
|
carry all claims to maturity, meet the reasonable expenses of |
|
148
|
conducting the business of the company, and maintain a |
|
149
|
reasonable surplus. The company shall conduct a medical |
|
150
|
malpractice insurance program that shall be neither more nor |
|
151
|
less than self-supporting.
|
|
152
|
Section 6. Board to determine investment policy; |
|
153
|
administrator to make investments; methodology.--The board shall |
|
154
|
formulate and adopt an investment policy and supervise the |
|
155
|
investment activities of the company. The administrator may |
|
156
|
invest and reinvest the surplus or reserves of the company |
|
157
|
subject to the limitations imposed on domestic insurance |
|
158
|
companies by state law. The company may retain an independent |
|
159
|
investment counsel. The board shall periodically review and |
|
160
|
appraise the investment strategy being followed and the |
|
161
|
effectiveness of such services. Any investment counsel retained |
|
162
|
or hired shall periodically report to the board on investment |
|
163
|
results and related matters.
|
|
164
|
Section 7. Agents may sell policies; commissions.--Any |
|
165
|
insurance agent or broker licensed to sell medical malpractice |
|
166
|
insurance in this state shall be authorized to sell insurance |
|
167
|
policies for the company in compliance with the bylaws adopted |
|
168
|
by the company. The board shall establish a schedule of |
|
169
|
commissions to pay for the services of the agent.
|
|
170
|
Section 8. Medical malpractice risk management program; |
|
171
|
administrator to formulate; effect of compliance with program on |
|
172
|
premiums.--
|
|
173
|
(1) The administrator shall formulate, implement, and |
|
174
|
monitor a medical malpractice risk management program for all |
|
175
|
policyholders.
|
|
176
|
(2) The company shall have representatives whose sole |
|
177
|
purpose is to develop with policyholders a written medical |
|
178
|
malpractice risk management plan which is based upon clearly |
|
179
|
stated goals and objectives. The company shall communicate the |
|
180
|
importance of such a plan and assist in any way to attain such |
|
181
|
goals and objectives.
|
|
182
|
(3) The administrator or board may refuse to insure or may |
|
183
|
terminate the insurance of any insured who disregards the |
|
184
|
medical malpractice risk management plan.
|
|
185
|
(4) In determining the premium payable by an insured, the |
|
186
|
company shall consider the compliance of the insured with the |
|
187
|
company’s medical malpractice risk management plan.
|
|
188
|
Section 9. Company not to receive state appropriation; |
|
189
|
exception; revenue bonds; authorization; terms; execution; |
|
190
|
procedures.--
|
|
191
|
(1) The company shall not receive any state appropriation, |
|
192
|
directly or indirectly, except as provided in subsection (2).
|
|
193
|
(2) After July 1, 2003, the director of the Office of |
|
194
|
Insurance Regulation shall make one or more loans to the company |
|
195
|
in an amount not to exceed an aggregate amount of $5 million |
|
196
|
from the General Revenue fund for startup funding and initial |
|
197
|
capitalization of the company. The board of the company shall |
|
198
|
make application to the Office of Insurance Regulation for the |
|
199
|
loans, stating the amount to be loaned to the company. The loans |
|
200
|
shall be for a term of 5 years and, at the time the application |
|
201
|
for such loans is approved, shall bear interest at an annual |
|
202
|
rate determined by the director of the Office of Insurance |
|
203
|
Regulation.
|
|
204
|
(3) In order to provide funds for the creation, continued |
|
205
|
development, and operation of the company, the board is |
|
206
|
authorized to issue revenue bonds, from time to time, in a |
|
207
|
principal amount outstanding not to exceed $40 million at any |
|
208
|
given time, payable solely from premiums received from insurance |
|
209
|
policies and other revenues generated by the company.
|
|
210
|
(4) The board may issue bonds to refund other bonds issued |
|
211
|
pursuant to this section.
|
|
212
|
(5) The bonds shall have a maturity of no more than 10 |
|
213
|
years from the date of issuance. The board shall determine all |
|
214
|
other terms, covenants, and conditions of the bonds, except that |
|
215
|
no bonds may be redeemed prior to maturity unless the company |
|
216
|
has established adequate reserves for the risks it has insured.
|
|
217
|
(6) The bonds shall be executed with the manual or |
|
218
|
facsimile signature of the administrator or the chair of the |
|
219
|
board and attested by another member of the board. The bonds may |
|
220
|
bear the seal, if any, of the company.
|
|
221
|
(7) The proceeds of the bonds and the earnings on those |
|
222
|
proceeds shall be used by the board for the development and |
|
223
|
operation of the company, to pay expenses incurred in the |
|
224
|
preparation, issuance, and sale of the bonds, and to pay any |
|
225
|
obligations relating to the bonds and the proceeds of the bonds |
|
226
|
under the United States Internal Revenue Code.
|
|
227
|
(8) The bonds may be sold at a public or private sale. If |
|
228
|
the bonds are sold at a public sale, the notice of sale and |
|
229
|
other procedures for the sale shall be determined by the |
|
230
|
administrator or the company.
|
|
231
|
(9) This section constitutes the full authority for the |
|
232
|
issuance and sale of the bonds, and the bonds shall not be |
|
233
|
invalid for any irregularity or defect in the proceedings for |
|
234
|
their issuance and sale and shall be incontestable in the hands |
|
235
|
of bona fide purchasers or holders of the bonds for value.
|
|
236
|
(10) An amount of money from the sources specified in |
|
237
|
subsection (2) sufficient to pay the principal of and any |
|
238
|
interest on the bonds as they become due each year shall be set |
|
239
|
aside and is hereby pledged for the payment of the principal and |
|
240
|
interest on the bonds.
|
|
241
|
(11) The bonds shall be legal investments for any person |
|
242
|
or board charged with the investment of public funds and may be |
|
243
|
accepted as security for any deposit of public money, and the |
|
244
|
bonds and interest thereon are exempt from taxation by the state |
|
245
|
and any political subdivision or agency of the state.
|
|
246
|
(12) The bonds shall be payable by the company, which |
|
247
|
shall keep a complete record relating to the payment of the |
|
248
|
bonds.
|
|
249
|
(13) Not more than 50 percent of the bonds sold shall be |
|
250
|
sold to public entities.
|
|
251
|
Section 10. Audit required; procedure; report; contents; |
|
252
|
Governor and Legislature to receive; administrator to formulate |
|
253
|
budget; Office of Insurance Regulation; duties.--
|
|
254
|
(1) The board shall cause an annual audit of the books of |
|
255
|
accounts, funds, and securities of the company to be made by a |
|
256
|
competent and independent firm of certified public accountants, |
|
257
|
the cost of the audit to be charged against the company. A copy |
|
258
|
of the audit report shall be filed with the director of the |
|
259
|
Department of Insurance and the administrator. The audit shall |
|
260
|
be open to the public for inspection.
|
|
261
|
(2) The board shall submit an annual independently audited |
|
262
|
report in accordance with procedures governing annual reports |
|
263
|
adopted by the National Association of Insurance Commissioners |
|
264
|
by March 1 of each year, and the report shall be delivered to |
|
265
|
the Governor, the President of the Senate, and the Speaker of |
|
266
|
the House of Representatives. The report shall indicate the |
|
267
|
business conducted by the company during the previous year and |
|
268
|
contain a statement of the resources and liabilities of the |
|
269
|
company.
|
|
270
|
(3) The administrator shall annually submit to the board |
|
271
|
for its approval an estimated budget of the entire expense of |
|
272
|
administering the company for the succeeding calendar year |
|
273
|
having due regard for the business interests and contract |
|
274
|
obligations of the company.
|
|
275
|
(4) The incurred loss experience and expense of the |
|
276
|
company shall be ascertained each year to include, but not be |
|
277
|
limited to, estimates of outstanding liabilities for claims |
|
278
|
reported to the company but not yet paid and liabilities for |
|
279
|
claims arising from injuries which have occurred but have not |
|
280
|
yet been reported to the company. If there is an excess of |
|
281
|
assets over liabilities, necessary reserves, and a reasonable |
|
282
|
surplus, a cash dividend shall be declared or a credit allowed |
|
283
|
to any health care provider who has complied with the company’s |
|
284
|
medical malpractice risk management program.
|
|
285
|
(5) The Office of Insurance Regulation shall conduct an |
|
286
|
examination of the company in the manner and under the |
|
287
|
conditions provided by the statutes of the insurance code for |
|
288
|
the examination of insurance carriers. The company is subject to |
|
289
|
all provisions of law which relate to private insurance carriers |
|
290
|
and to the jurisdiction of the Office of Insurance Regulation in |
|
291
|
the same manner as private insurance carriers, except as |
|
292
|
provided by the director.
|
|
293
|
Section 11. Medical malpractice rate standards and prior |
|
294
|
approval of rates.--
|
|
295
|
(1) In addition to any other requirements imposed by law, |
|
296
|
the rates for each self-insurance policy as authorized under s. |
|
297
|
627.357, Florida Statutes, or an insurance policy providing |
|
298
|
coverage for claims arising out of the rendering of, or the |
|
299
|
failure to render, medical care or services, shall be set by the |
|
300
|
director of the Office of Insurance Regulation and shall not be |
|
301
|
excessive, inadequate, or unfairly discriminatory.
|
|
302
|
(2) As to all rate filings subject to approval in |
|
303
|
accordance with this section:
|
|
304
|
(a) Insurers or rating organizations shall apply for |
|
305
|
rates, rating schedules, or rating manuals to allow the insurer |
|
306
|
a reasonable rate of return on such classes of insurance written |
|
307
|
in this state. A copy of rates, rating schedules, rating |
|
308
|
manuals, premium credits, or discount schedules and surcharge |
|
309
|
schedules, and changes thereto, shall be filed with the Office |
|
310
|
of Insurance Regulation. The filing must be made at least 180 |
|
311
|
days before the proposed effective date, and the filing shall |
|
312
|
not be implemented during the Office of Insurance Regulation’s |
|
313
|
review of the filing and any proceeding and judicial review.
|
|
314
|
(b) Upon receiving a rate filing and within a reasonable |
|
315
|
time, the Office of Insurance Regulation shall review the rate |
|
316
|
filing and set a rate or rate schedule that is not excessive, |
|
317
|
inadequate, or unfairly discriminatory. In making that |
|
318
|
determination, the Office of Insurance Regulation shall, in |
|
319
|
accordance with generally accepted and reasonable actuarial |
|
320
|
techniques, consider the following factors:
|
|
321
|
1. Past and prospective loss experience within and without |
|
322
|
this state and the insurer or self insurer’s past and |
|
323
|
prospective loss experience within this state, if applicable. A |
|
324
|
medical malpractice insurer shall consider past and prospective |
|
325
|
loss experience and catastrophic hazards, if any, solely within |
|
326
|
this state. However, if there is insufficient experience within |
|
327
|
this state upon which a rate can be based, the insurer may |
|
328
|
consider experiences within any other state or states which have |
|
329
|
a similar cost of claim and frequency of claim experience as |
|
330
|
this state and, if insufficient experience is available, the |
|
331
|
insurer may use nationwide experience. The insurer, in its rate |
|
332
|
filing or in its records, shall expressly show the rate |
|
333
|
experience it is using. In considering experience outside this |
|
334
|
state, as much weight as possible shall be given to state |
|
335
|
experience.
|
|
336
|
2. Past and prospective expenses.
|
|
337
|
3. Investment income reasonably expected by the insurer, |
|
338
|
consistent with the insurer's investment practices, from |
|
339
|
investable premiums anticipated in the filing, plus any other |
|
340
|
expected income from currently invested assets representing the |
|
341
|
amount expected on unearned premium reserves, loss reserves, and |
|
342
|
surplus. The Office of Insurance Regulation may adopt rules |
|
343
|
using reasonable techniques of actuarial science and economics |
|
344
|
to specify the manner in which insurers shall calculate |
|
345
|
investment income attributable to such classes of insurance |
|
346
|
written in this state and the manner in which such investment |
|
347
|
income shall be used in the calculation of insurance rates. Such |
|
348
|
manner shall contemplate allowances for an underwriting profit |
|
349
|
factor and full consideration of investment income which |
|
350
|
produces a reasonable rate of return. The profit and contingency |
|
351
|
factor as specified in the filing shall be used in computing |
|
352
|
excess profits in conjunction with s. 627.0625, Florida |
|
353
|
Statutes.
|
|
354
|
4. The reasonableness of the judgment reflected in the |
|
355
|
filing.
|
|
356
|
5. Dividends, savings, or unabsorbed premium deposits |
|
357
|
allowed or returned to policyholders, members, or subscribers in |
|
358
|
this state.
|
|
359
|
6. The adequacy of loss reserves.
|
|
360
|
7. The cost of reinsurance.
|
|
361
|
8. Trend factors, including trends in actual losses per |
|
362
|
insured unit for the insurer making the filing.
|
|
363
|
9. A reasonable margin for underwriting profit and |
|
364
|
contingencies.
|
|
365
|
10. The cost of medical services.
|
|
366
|
11. Other relevant factors which impact upon the frequency |
|
367
|
or severity of claims or upon expenses.
|
|
368
|
12. Other relevant public policy considerations.
|
|
369
|
(c) After consideration of the rate factors provided in |
|
370
|
paragraph (b), the Office of Insurance Regulation shall |
|
371
|
determine and set the appropriate rate, as long as the rate is |
|
372
|
not excessive, inadequate, or unfairly discriminatory based upon |
|
373
|
the following standards:
|
|
374
|
1. Rates shall be deemed excessive if they are likely to |
|
375
|
produce a profit from Florida business that is unreasonably high |
|
376
|
in relation to the risk involved in the class of business or if |
|
377
|
expenses are unreasonably high in relation to services rendered.
|
|
378
|
2. Rates shall be deemed excessive if, among other things, |
|
379
|
the rate structure established by a stock insurance company |
|
380
|
provides for replenishment of reserves or surpluses from |
|
381
|
premiums when the replenishment is attributable to investment |
|
382
|
losses, the rate is unreasonably high for the insurance |
|
383
|
provided, or expenses are unreasonably high in relation to |
|
384
|
services rendered.
|
|
385
|
3. Rates shall be deemed inadequate if they are clearly |
|
386
|
insufficient, together with the investment income attributable |
|
387
|
to them, to sustain projected losses and expenses in the class |
|
388
|
of business to which they apply and the continued use of such |
|
389
|
rate endangers the solvency of the insurer using the rate.
|
|
390
|
4. A rating plan, including discounts, credits, or |
|
391
|
surcharges, shall be deemed unfairly discriminatory if the plan |
|
392
|
fails to clearly and equitably reflect consideration of the |
|
393
|
policyholder's participation in a risk management program |
|
394
|
adopted pursuant to s. 627.0625, Florida Statutes, or the |
|
395
|
policyholder’s individual claims history, unless price |
|
396
|
differentials fail to reflect equitably the differences in |
|
397
|
expected losses and experiences.
|
|
398
|
5. A rate shall be deemed inadequate as to the premium |
|
399
|
charged to a risk or group of risks if discounts or credits are |
|
400
|
allowed which exceed a reasonable reflection of expense savings |
|
401
|
and reasonably expected loss experience from the risk or group |
|
402
|
of risks.
|
|
403
|
6. A rate shall be deemed unfairly discriminatory as to a |
|
404
|
risk or group of risks if the application of premium discounts, |
|
405
|
credits, or surcharges among such risks does not bear a |
|
406
|
reasonable relationship to the expected loss and expense |
|
407
|
experience among the various risks.
|
|
408
|
(d) In addition to the standards set forth in paragraph |
|
409
|
(c), the Office of Insurance Regulation shall disapprove rates |
|
410
|
that are 15 percent greater or less than the current approved |
|
411
|
rate of the insurer or self-insurer.
|
|
412
|
(e) In reviewing a rate filing, the Office of Insurance |
|
413
|
Regulation may require the insurer to provide at the insurer's |
|
414
|
expense all information necessary to evaluate the condition of |
|
415
|
the company and the reasonableness of the filing according to |
|
416
|
the criteria enumerated in this section.
|
|
417
|
1. The director shall adopt rules which shall require each |
|
418
|
medical malpractice insurer to record and report its loss and |
|
419
|
expense experience and such other data, including reserves, as |
|
420
|
may be necessary to determine whether rates comply with the |
|
421
|
standards set forth in this section. Every medical malpractice |
|
422
|
insurer shall provide such information in such form as the |
|
423
|
director may require.
|
|
424
|
2. The director shall require that the annual report and |
|
425
|
any such supplemental report which contains information of a |
|
426
|
company’s loss and loss adjustment reserves be accompanied by an |
|
427
|
opinion signed and sworn to by a qualified and independent |
|
428
|
actuary verifying that, within the 9 months prior to the |
|
429
|
submission of the report, the actuary has conducted a review and |
|
430
|
analysis of the insurance company’s loss and loss adjustment |
|
431
|
reserves, the reserves are computed in accordance with accepted |
|
432
|
loss reserving standards, and the reserves are fairly stated in |
|
433
|
accordance with sound loss reserving principles.
|
|
434
|
3. The director shall maintain for at least 10 years by |
|
435
|
carrier all reports submitted by insurers pursuant to rules |
|
436
|
adopted by the director under this section. The director shall |
|
437
|
consider these reports in determining the appropriateness of |
|
438
|
premium rates for medical malpractice insurance.
|
|
439
|
4. The director may examine and review the assignment and |
|
440
|
assessment of risk for different classifications for different |
|
441
|
specialties or practices of medicine. The director may hold a |
|
442
|
public hearing on any filing containing a risk assignment for |
|
443
|
medical malpractice insurance to determine whether such risk |
|
444
|
assignment for medical malpractice insurance is reasonable and |
|
445
|
may issue orders concerning such risk assignment.
|
|
446
|
(3)(a) Every medical malpractice insurer shall file with |
|
447
|
the Office of Insurance Regulation every manual of |
|
448
|
classifications, rules, and rates, every rating plan, and every |
|
449
|
modification of any of the foregoing which the insurer proposes |
|
450
|
to use in this state.
|
|
451
|
(b) The expense provisions included in the rates to be |
|
452
|
used by a medical malpractice insurer shall reflect the |
|
453
|
operating methods of the insurer and, so far as it is credible |
|
454
|
and reasonable, its own actual and anticipated expense |
|
455
|
experience.
|
|
456
|
(c) The rates to be used by a medical malpractice insurer |
|
457
|
shall contain provisions for contingencies and an allowance |
|
458
|
permitting a reasonable rate of return. In determining a |
|
459
|
reasonable rate of return, consideration shall be given to all |
|
460
|
investment income reasonably attributable to medical malpractice |
|
461
|
insurance.
|
|
462
|
(d) Every filing shall state the proposed effective date |
|
463
|
of the filing, shall indicate the character and extent of the |
|
464
|
coverage contemplated, and shall contain supporting information. |
|
465
|
Such supporting information may include the experience or |
|
466
|
judgment of the insurer making the filing; the insurer’s |
|
467
|
interpretation of any statistical data the insurer relied upon; |
|
468
|
the experience of other insurers; and any other factors which |
|
469
|
the insurer deems relevant.
|
|
470
|
(4) The Office of Insurance Regulation may at any time |
|
471
|
review a rate, rating schedule, rating manual, or rate change, |
|
472
|
the pertinent records of the insurer, and market conditions. If |
|
473
|
the Office of Insurance Regulation finds on a preliminary basis |
|
474
|
that a rate may be excessive, inadequate, or unfairly |
|
475
|
discriminatory, the office shall initiate proceedings to set a |
|
476
|
new rate and shall so notify the insurer. However, the office |
|
477
|
may not disapprove as excessive any rate it has set for a period |
|
478
|
of 1 year after the effective date of the filing unless the |
|
479
|
office finds that a material misrepresentation or material error |
|
480
|
was made by the insurer or was contained in the filing. Upon |
|
481
|
being so notified, the insurer or rating organization shall, |
|
482
|
within 60 days, file with the office all information which, in |
|
483
|
the belief of the insurer or organization, proves the |
|
484
|
reasonableness, adequacy, and fairness of the rate or rate |
|
485
|
change. The office shall determine and set an appropriate rate |
|
486
|
within a reasonable time after receipt of the insurer’s initial |
|
487
|
response, pursuant to the procedures of paragraphs (2)(b)-(e). |
|
488
|
In such instances and in any administrative proceeding relating |
|
489
|
to the legality of any rate, the insurer or rating organization |
|
490
|
shall carry the burden of proof by a preponderance of the |
|
491
|
evidence to show that the rate is not excessive, inadequate, or |
|
492
|
unfairly discriminatory.
|
|
493
|
(5) When the Office of Insurance Regulation sets a new |
|
494
|
rate or rate schedule, the office shall issue an order |
|
495
|
specifying the new rate or rate schedule and the findings of the |
|
496
|
office. The order shall constitute agency action for purposes of |
|
497
|
the Administrative Procedure Act.
|
|
498
|
(6) Except as otherwise specifically provided in chapter |
|
499
|
627, Florida Statutes, the Office of Insurance Regulation shall |
|
500
|
not prohibit any insurer, including any residual market plan or |
|
501
|
joint underwriting association, from paying acquisition costs |
|
502
|
based on the full amount of premium, as defined in s. 627.403, |
|
503
|
Florida Statutes, applicable to any policy or prohibit any such |
|
504
|
insurer from including the full amount of acquisition costs in a |
|
505
|
rate filing.
|
|
506
|
(7) The establishment of any rate, rating classification, |
|
507
|
rating plan or schedule, or variation thereof in violation of |
|
508
|
part IX of chapter 626, Florida Statutes, is also in violation |
|
509
|
of this section.
|
|
510
|
(8) The submission of rates, rating schedules, and rating |
|
511
|
manuals to the Office of Insurance Regulation by a licensed |
|
512
|
rating organization of which an insurer is a member or |
|
513
|
subscriber will be sufficient compliance with this section for |
|
514
|
any insurer maintaining membership or subscribership in such |
|
515
|
organization, to the extent that the insurer uses the rates, |
|
516
|
rating schedules, and rating manuals of such organization. All |
|
517
|
such information shall be available for public inspection, upon |
|
518
|
receipt by the office, during usual business hours.
|
|
519
|
(9) The initial submission of a rate by an insurer or |
|
520
|
self-insurer shall be deemed inadequate or excessive if the rate |
|
521
|
is less than or exceeds the average aggregate rate of the |
|
522
|
individual insurer or self-insurer with at least 10-percent |
|
523
|
market share in this state for the previous calendar year.
|
|
524
|
Section 12. Subsection (7) is added to section 627.062, |
|
525
|
Florida Statutes, to read: |
|
526
|
627.062 Rate standards.-- |
|
527
|
(7) This section shall not apply to professional medical |
|
528
|
malpractice insurance.
|
|
529
|
Section 13. Section 627.3518, Florida Statutes, is created |
|
530
|
to read: |
|
531
|
627.3518 Rates for medical malpractice insurance.--
|
|
532
|
(1) No insurer issuing policies of medical malpractice |
|
533
|
insurance in this state may use a rate in excess of the rate |
|
534
|
such insurer used in this state on January 1, 2001. Insurers |
|
535
|
issuing polices of medical malpractice insurance if such insurer |
|
536
|
had no rates in effect in this state on January 1, 2001, may not |
|
537
|
use rates that exceed the rates used by the insurer with the |
|
538
|
most policies of medical malpractice insurance in effect in this |
|
539
|
state on January 1, 2001.
|
|
540
|
(2) Each insurer’s rates for medical malpractice insurance |
|
541
|
may be increased only if the Chief Financial Officer determines, |
|
542
|
after a hearing, that the insurer is substantially threatened |
|
543
|
with insolvency unless its rates for medical malpractice |
|
544
|
insurance are increased. In such cases, the Chief Financial |
|
545
|
Officer shall set the medical malpractice insurance rates for |
|
546
|
such insurer. Rates set by the Chief Financial Officer may not |
|
547
|
be excessive, inadequate, or unfairly discriminatory. |
|
548
|
Section 14. Section 627.352, Florida Statutes, is created |
|
549
|
to read: |
|
550
|
627.352 Medical malpractice insurance; issuance required |
|
551
|
of certain insurers.--No insurer may issue policies of motor |
|
552
|
vehicle insurance, commercial property insurance, or residential |
|
553
|
property insurance in this state unless such insurer also issues |
|
554
|
policies of medical malpractice insurance in this state. No |
|
555
|
insurer issuing policies of medical malpractice insurance may |
|
556
|
deny issuance of a policy of medical malpractice insurance to |
|
557
|
any health care provider unless such denial is based on |
|
558
|
underwriting standards approved by the Chief Financial Officer.
|
|
559
|
Section 15. Subsection (10) of section 627.357, Florida |
|
560
|
Statutes, is amended to read: |
|
561
|
627.357 Medical malpractice self-insurance.-- |
|
562
|
(10) A self-insurance fund may not be formed under this |
|
563
|
section after October 1, 1992.
|
|
564
|
Section 16. Paragraph (a) of subsection (5) of section |
|
565
|
766.314, Florida Statutes, is amended to read: |
|
566
|
766.314 Assessments; plan of operation.-- |
|
567
|
(5)(a)1.Beginning January 1, 1990, the persons and |
|
568
|
entities listed in paragraphs (4)(b) and (c), except those |
|
569
|
persons or entities who are specifically excluded from said |
|
570
|
provisions, as of the date determined in accordance with the |
|
571
|
plan of operation, taking into account persons licensed |
|
572
|
subsequent to the payment of the initial assessment, shall pay |
|
573
|
an annual assessment in the amount equal to the initial |
|
574
|
assessments provided in paragraphs (4)(b) and (c). On January 1, |
|
575
|
1991, and on each January 1 thereafter, the association shall |
|
576
|
determine the amount of additional assessments necessary |
|
577
|
pursuant to subsection (7), in the manner required by the plan |
|
578
|
of operation, subject to any increase determined to be necessary |
|
579
|
by the Department of Insurance pursuant to paragraph (7)(b). On |
|
580
|
July 1, 1991, and on each July 1 thereafter, the persons and |
|
581
|
entities listed in paragraphs (4)(b) and (c), except those |
|
582
|
persons or entities who are specifically excluded from said |
|
583
|
provisions, shall pay the additional assessments which were |
|
584
|
determined on January 1. Beginning January 1, 1990, the entities |
|
585
|
listed in paragraph (4)(a), including those licensed on or after |
|
586
|
October 1, 1988, shall pay an annual assessment of $50 per |
|
587
|
infant delivered during the prior calendar year. The additional |
|
588
|
assessments which were determined on January 1, 1991, pursuant |
|
589
|
to the provisions of subsection (7) shall not be due and payable |
|
590
|
by the entities listed in paragraph (4)(a) until July 1. |
|
591
|
2. Any person or entity listed in paragraph (4)(b) or |
|
592
|
paragraph (4)(c) who paid the annual assessment specified in |
|
593
|
this section for the year beginning July 1, 2001, and the year |
|
594
|
beginning July 1, 2002, shall be exempt from payment of the |
|
595
|
annual assessment for the year beginning July 1, 2003, and the |
|
596
|
year beginning July 1, 2004.
|
|
597
|
Section 17. This act shall take effect upon becoming a law |
|
598
|
and shall apply to policies issued or renewed after that date, |
|
599
|
and shall apply to all rates, rating schedules, or rating |
|
600
|
manuals submitted to the Office of Insurance Regulation on or |
|
601
|
after July 1, 2003. |